
Should You Lease or Buy a Car?
Two people want the same $40,000 car. One leases it for $625 a month. The other finances it for $773 a month. The leaser looks like the smart one, saving nearly $150 every month.
Eight years later, the buyer has spent tens of thousands of dollars less. Both of those statements are true, and understanding why is the whole answer to the lease-or-buy question.
Start with the arithmetic, not the payment
Here is the example in full. The figures are illustrative, rounded, and assume the same car, the same 6 percent rate, and that the car is worth 58 percent of its price after three years. Your deal will differ, but the shape of the result rarely does.
The lease. 36 months, 12,000 miles a year, $2,000 due at signing to cover fees and the first payment, then about $625 a month before sales tax. Three years costs roughly $24,500, and at the end you hand the keys back and own nothing.
The loan. $40,000 over 60 months at 6 percent with no deposit comes to about $773 a month, or roughly $46,400 in total, of which about $6,400 is interest. After three years you have paid about $27,800 and still owe about $17,400. But the car is worth around $23,200, so you have roughly $5,800 of equity. Your true cost for those three years is about $22,000, a little less than the lease.
The gap at three years is modest. The gap at eight years is not.
| Over 8 years | Lease, then lease again | Buy and keep |
|---|---|---|
| Payments made | About 96 months of payments, forever | 60 months, then none |
| Rough total paid | About $65,000 (8 years of $24,500 three-year cycles, at today's prices) | About $46,400 |
| What you own at the end | Nothing | A car with some resale value |
| Repairs out of warranty | Rarely, the car is always new | Likely in later years, budget for them |
| Mileage limits | Yes, every contract | None |
Even after setting aside several thousand dollars for repairs in years six to eight, the buyer who keeps the car comes out well ahead. The reason is depreciation. A new car loses value fastest in its early years, and a lease is essentially a contract to pay for that steep early slice, then start again with another brand new car and pay for its steep early slice too.
How a lease payment is actually built
Once you see the formula, lease quotes become much easier to argue with. A lease payment has two main parts.
- Depreciation. The agreed price of the car minus its predicted value at the end (the residual), spread across the months. In the example, $40,000 minus $23,200 is $16,800, over 36 months, which is about $467 a month.
- The finance charge. In the US this is usually expressed as a "money factor", a small decimal. Multiply by 2,400 to get a rough equivalent APR, so a money factor of 0.0025 is about 6 percent. The monthly charge is the money factor times the agreed price plus the residual, here about $158.
Add them together and you get roughly $625, before tax and fees. That tells you where the levers are. The price of the car is negotiable in a lease exactly as it is in a purchase, yet many people only negotiate the monthly figure. A higher residual lowers your payment, which is why cars that hold their value tend to lease well. And the money factor can be marked up by the dealer, so ask what it is and convert it to an APR before you sign.
The three questions that decide it
Rather than a pros and cons list, answer these honestly.
How long do you keep cars? If the answer is "until they die" or even "six years plus", buy. The payment-free years at the end are where buying pulls ahead, and a lease never gives you any. If you genuinely want a new car every three years, leasing narrows the gap considerably, because trading in a financed car every three years means repeatedly absorbing the steepest depreciation too.
How far and how hard do you drive? Leases come with an annual mileage allowance, and the FTC notes it is typically 15,000 miles or less. Go over and you pay a per-mile charge at the end. At an illustrative 25 cents a mile, driving 15,000 miles a year on a 12,000 mile lease leaves 9,000 excess miles after three years, which is $2,250 on handback. You also pay for "excess wear and damage", which covers the scuffed alloy, the cracked windscreen and the dog-scratched seats. Families with small children and long commuters are often better off owning.
Could your life change in the next three years? A job move, a new baby, a divorce or a lost income can all make the car wrong or unaffordable. Selling an owned car is straightforward. Ending a lease early can trigger what the FTC calls a substantial early termination charge, and Canada's FCAC similarly warns that breaking a lease may be very costly. If your future is uncertain, the flexibility of ownership has real value.
Leasing tends to make sense when all three answers point the same way: you like new cars, you drive modest predictable distances, and your circumstances are stable. It also makes more sense for the self-employed. In the US, business use of a vehicle can be deducted either with the IRS standard mileage rate or actual expenses, and lease payments can form part of actual expenses for the business share of use, with some limits. Check with a tax professional before letting tax drive the decision.
How it works in the US, UK and Canada
United States. Lease terms are commonly 24 to 48 months. In most states sales tax is charged on each monthly payment rather than on the full price, which is one reason leases look attractive on expensive cars, though rules vary by state. Many leases include gap coverage, which pays the difference if the car is written off while you owe more than it is worth, but check rather than assume. If you buy instead, the CFPB's auto loan tools are worth using before you set foot in a dealership, including getting a pre-approved rate so the dealer has something to beat. Avoid stretching a loan to 72 or 84 months just to match a lease payment, since that is how people end up owing more than the car is worth.
United Kingdom. What Americans call leasing is usually Personal Contract Hire (PCH): you pay monthly, hand the car back, and have no option to buy. The more common way to "buy" a new car is Personal Contract Purchase (PCP), which works a lot like a lease with an option at the end. Payments are low because a large final balloon payment is deferred, and you can pay it to keep the car, hand it back, or roll into a new deal. PCP and hire purchase agreements also carry a statutory right of voluntary termination once you have paid half the total amount payable, which PCH does not. Two more UK specifics: cars with a list price over £40,000 (with separate rules for some electric cars) pay an expensive car supplement on vehicle tax for five years, set out in GOV.UK's rate tables, and anyone who took out car finance between 2007 and November 2024 should keep an eye on the FCA's motor finance compensation scheme, which is currently delayed by a legal challenge.
Canada. The FCAC describes leasing as typically running three to five years, with the choice to buy the car, return it or lease another at the end. Leases usually set an annual kilometre allowance with a per-kilometre charge beyond it. GST or HST, and provincial sales tax where it applies, is charged on each lease payment. Before you sign, most provinces require the dealer to give you a disclosure statement setting out the total cost of the lease, so compare that total, not the payment. The federal Office of Consumer Affairs also runs a free vehicle lease or loan calculator, and reminds buyers that there is generally no cooling-off period once you sign with a dealer.
If you do lease, do it well
- Negotiate the vehicle price first, then the money factor, then the payment.
- Pick a mileage allowance slightly above what you expect to drive. Prepaid miles are cheaper than excess miles.
- Put as little cash down as possible. A large down payment on a lease is lost if the car is stolen or written off early.
- Get a pre-return inspection a couple of months before handback and fix minor damage yourself, often for less than the wear charge.
- Near the end, compare the buyout price with the car's market value. If the car is worth more than the residual, buying it out can be a bargain.
If you are buying, the cost of insuring the car matters too, and it varies more between models than most people expect. Our guide to how car insurance premiums are calculated explains what moves the price, and how to save money on car insurance covers the easiest wins.
The bottom line
A lease sells you the most expensive years of a car's life on repeat, in exchange for a lower payment, less hassle and a predictable exit. Buying costs more each month at first, then gets dramatically cheaper once the loan is gone. If you keep cars for many years, drive a lot, or your life might change, buy. If you want something new every few years, drive modest predictable distances and can live inside the contract's rules, a well-negotiated lease is a reasonable choice. Whichever you choose, compare the total cost over the same period, and never let the monthly payment make the decision for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it smarter to lease or buy a car?
For most people who keep cars a long time, buying is smarter because you stop making payments once the loan ends and keep driving an asset you own. Leasing can be the better fit if you want a new car every few years, drive predictable low mileage, want to avoid out-of-warranty repairs, or can claim the car as a business expense. Compare total cost over the same period rather than monthly payments.
What happens if you go over the mileage on a lease?
You pay a per-mile or per-kilometre charge for every unit over the allowance when you hand the car back, as set out in your contract. The FTC notes that leases commonly limit driving to around 15,000 miles a year or less. If you expect to drive more, it is usually cheaper to buy a higher allowance at the start than to pay the excess rate at the end.
Can you end a car lease early?
Usually yes, but it is rarely cheap. US and Canadian regulators both warn that early termination can be very costly, because you may owe the remaining payments or the gap between what you owe and the car's value. Alternatives include a lease transfer to another person where the lessor allows it, or buying the car out and selling it yourself.
Sources
Primary sources used for this guide. Last checked September 27, 2026.
- Financing or Leasing a CarUS Federal Trade Commission
- Auto loansUS Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Standard mileage ratesUS Internal Revenue Service
- Vehicle tax rate tablesGOV.UK
- Car finance claimsUK Financial Conduct Authority
- Car financing optionsFinancial Consumer Agency of Canada
Keep reading
Cars
New vs Used Car: Which Saves You More?
A used car usually costs less per year to own, but not always. See the cost-per-year maths for new, 3-year-old and 7-year-old cars, plus US, UK and CA checks.
Housing
How to Save on Closing Costs When Buying a Home
Sort closing costs into fixed, shoppable and negotiable, then cut each one. Worked examples on points, fees and stamp duty, plus US, UK and Canada rules.